Article
Indexed investments have grown in popularity. While attention in the last few years had mainly concentrated on exchange-traded funds (ETFs), the focus has recently shifted to include index funds as well. Both product classes are transparent, cost-efficient investment options, yet they differ from one another and have their own specific advantages.
March 16, 2020
Investors in ETFs and index funds not only save on fees, but also save time. Passive investments of this kind do not require stock picking or constant monitoring of the markets. This is because index funds and ETFs track a benchmark index as precisely as possible, very closely mirroring its performance. Since they track an entire market, passive funds are diversified, thus minimizing risk.
Active funds, in contrast, always try to beat the market, i.e. they strive to achieve a better return than their benchmark index. However, numerous studies have shown that few actively managed funds actually succeed in outperforming their respective indices over the long term.1 Consequently, passive investments now account for one-third of all mutual fund assets invested worldwide (see pie chart). Around 70% of passively managed assets are invested in unlisted index funds and only around 30% in ETFs.
The answer to the question of which are better depends on the chosen investment strategy and the planned holding period. It is often advisable to have a combination of ETFs and index funds in one’s portfolio.
One of the criteria for deciding between index funds and ETFs is tradability. If intraday tradability is a crucial requirement, then only ETFs are worth considering. Since ETFs are listed on securities exchanges, market makers guarantee trading liquidity. Calculation agents continually calculate the indicative net asset value (iNAV) on which market makers base their binding bid and ask prices.
Shares of index funds, in contrast, can only be directly bought from or sold to the fund provider at their net asset value (NAV) once a day. Whenever investors buy or sell shares of index funds, they incur transaction costs in the form of issue spreads or redemption spreads. This mechanism is also referred to as dilution protection for existing investors.
The table below provides guidance on choosing the right product:
Unlike the big difference in tradability, there is hardly any difference between ETFs and index funds in terms of their total expense ratio (TER). The fund’s country of domicile and the resulting tax consequences are important aspects to consider when making a choice. Depending on the circumstances and the type of investor, ETFs and index funds can both have their advantages.
Apart from being subject to different withholding tax rates, another major differentiating factor for ETFs and index funds in Switzerland is the stamp duty. Like stocks, ETFs, too, are subject to a stamp duty on both buying and selling transactions. However, whereas the stamp duty paid when buying or selling ETFs domiciled in Switzerland currently amounts to 0.075%, it is 0.15% for foreign ETFs.
Unlisted Swiss funds, in contrast, are not subject to any stamp duty on purchases or redemptions. When buying shares in a foreign-domiciled index fund, investors have to pay a stamp duty currently amounting to 0.15%; only redemptions are exempt from the stamp tax.
When looking at the expenses over a given period, it becomes clear that private investors who wish to hold an ETF only for a short period can expect to pay high costs. This is because a stamp duty is incurred on each transaction. Index funds therefore are usually a better solution than ETFs for private investors in Switzerland who have a relatively short-term investment horizon. From a long-term perspective, though, it is wise to pay particular attention to administrative costs (ongoing costs) and tax efficiency related to withholding taxes.
Investors who are thinking about investing in an index through either ETFs or index funds should first analyze the benefits of the two types of funds. Whether ETFs or index funds are the better option depends on the market, the fund’s country of domicile and the investor’s tradability needs.
Investments in financial instruments can entail market risks as well as the risk of loss of capital, as they are subject to developments on the financial markets, which are not precisely foreseeable. The exact risk profile of Credit Suisse Index Fund Solutions is determined by the selection of the specific sub-fund and depends on the replicated indices. Unlike active investments, passive investments are strictly linked to the respective market, which is why a passive investment can be expected to incur a loss that is proportionate to any market loss. This also means that a significant outperformance can not be expected.
Sources
1 According to the Standard & Poor’s Index vs. Active (SPIVA) Scorecard, only 21.5% of active US equity funds outperformed the S&P 500 Index over a five-year period (see https://us.spindices.com/spiva).
This material has been prepared by the International Wealth Management division of Credit Suisse AG (“Credit Suisse”) and not by Credit Suisse's Research Department. It is intended only to provide observations and views of the said individual International Wealth Management personnel. Observations and views of the individual International Wealth Management personnel may be different from, or inconsistent with, the observations and views of Credit Suisse analysts or other International Wealth Management personnel, or the proprietary positions of Credit Suisse.
This material is provided for informational and illustrative purposes only. It does not constitute investment research, research recommendations, investment recommendations or information recommending or suggesting an investment strategy, and it does not contain research or financial analysis. This material does not constitute an invitation or an offer to the public or on a private basis to subscribe for or purchase any of the products or services mentioned. The information contained in this document has been provided as a general market commentary only and does not constitute any form of personal recommendation, investment advice, legal, tax, accounting or other advice or recommendation or any other financial service. It does not take into account the investment objectives, financial situation or needs, or knowledge and experience of any persons. The information provided is not intended to provide a sufficient basis on which to make an investment decision. Credit Suisse recommends that any person potentially interested in the elements described in this document shall seek to obtain relevant information and advice (including but not limited to risks) prior to taking any investment decision.
The information contained herein was provided as at the date of writing, and may no longer be up to date on the date on which the reader may receive or access the information. This information may change at any time without notice and with no obligation to update.
To the extent that these materials contain statements about future performance, such statements are forward looking and subject to a number of risks and uncertainties. It should be noted that historical returns, good past performance and financial market scenarios are no reliable indicator of good future performance. Significant losses are always possible.
Every investment involves risk and in volatile or uncertain market conditions, significant fluctuations in the value or return on that investment may occur. Investments in foreign securities or currencies involve additional risk as the foreign security or currency might lose value against the investor's reference currency. Alternative investments products and investment strategies (e.g. Hedge Funds or Private Equity) may be complex and may carry a higher degree of risk. Such risks can arise from extensive use of short sales, derivatives and leverage. Furthermore, the minimum investment periods for such investments may be longer than traditional investment products. Alternative investment strategies (e.g. Hedge Funds) are intended only for investors who understand and accept the risks associated with investments in such products.
Information and opinions presented in this material have been obtained or derived from sources which are deemed reliable, but neither Credit Suisse nor any entity of its group make any representation nor give any guarantee as to their accuracy, adequacy, quality or completeness. Unless indicated to the contrary, all figures are unaudited. All valuations mentioned herein are subject to Credit Suisse valuation policies and procedures.
No guarantee is given regarding the reliability or completeness of the information (including but not limited to numerical data, comments, analyses, opinions, estimations and strategies) contained in this document, and neither Credit Suisse nor any entity of its group may be held liable for direct, indirect or incidental, special or consequential damages resulting or arising from the use of these materials, regardless of whether such damages are foreseeable or not. The liability of Credit Suisse or any entity of its group may not be engaged as regards any investment, divestment or retention decision taken by a person on the basis of the information contained in this document. Such person shall bear alone all risks of losses potentially incurred as a result of such decision.
This material is not directed to, or intended for distribution to or use by, any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of, or is located in, any jurisdiction where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to applicable law or regulation, or which would subject Credit Suisse and/or its subsidiaries or affiliates to any registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction. This material is confidential and has been provided to its recipient and should not be copied, duplicated, distributed, published or otherwise transmitted to another person on whole or in part without the express written consent of Credit Suisse.
The recipient is informed that a possible business connection may exist between an issuer referenced in the present document and an entity part of the Credit Suisse group and that it may not be excluded that potential conflict of interests may result from such connection.
Copyright © 2020 Credit Suisse Group AG and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved.