Contact

Menu

Article

The technology race in Electric Vehicles

The Climate Change topic has captured the public and media interest for quite some time now. With the popularity rise of this theme, other related topics rode the same wave and became object of interest for the mainstream media.

June 18, 2019

M. Bruno Azevedo

Analyst, Credit Suisse Asset Management

The technology race in Electric Vehicles

The popularity of Electric Vehicles (EV)

Using Google Trends score as a popularity proxy, we observe that the Climate Change topic reached its popularity peak in 2009 (December); this was most likely driven by the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen at the same date. As for the EV topic, its popularity peaked by mid-2008. We can think of two potential causes for this 2008 spike: first, the media excitement around the Tesla Roadster, the first production EV to use lithium-ion cells and also the first to have a range over 200 miles1; second, the use of the EV topic by the candidate Barack Obama.

Google Trends Popularity Score of EVs and Climate Change

Fig. 1: Google Trends Popularity Score of EVs and Climate Change

Source: Google Trends, 12.03.2019

Fast forward 11 years to 2019, and the EV topic has seen its popularity rising for an extended period of time. These are good news for the Copenhagen Accord of 2009, described by Ban Ki-moon as a “significant step towards a global agreement to reduce and limit greenhouse gas emissions”2.

Tying all the knots together, we are led to conclude that the EV topic is an effect of all the climate action plans enacted by different governments across the world. It is now fairly well accepted that the path to decarbonisation of road-based transport will be composed of EVs. However, it is also true that there is still significant debate among industry experts on which type of technology will be the winner in powering the future of transportation.

"At Toyota, we are looking out 50 years and even more decades into the future. I do believe that the fuel-cell vehicle is the ultimate environmentally friendly car."

AkioToyoda, CEO Toyota
Source: https://www.boyden.com/media/toyotas-hydrogen-fuel-cell-hopes-170140/index.html

In this Thematic Insight we discuss the potential of an emerging technology, Hydrogen Fuel Cells, as an application for road-based transportation. Then, we assess how this technology compares with the more common Lithium-ion batteries.

The case for Hydrogen Fuel Cells

The market share of EVs has undoubtedly been growing at a fast pace. National governments have provided a wide array of incentives to drive EV adoption, while other stakeholders such as automakers have been increasing the number of available models, as well as heavily investing in research and development. Despite the progress, the market share of EVs is still residual, and largely dominated by battery electric vehicles (BEVs).

One important insight about the current state of EVs adoption, is the fact that the most common technology used in passenger cars (Lithium-ion), does not seem to fit the demand requirements of some market segments. The long-range, and the high-utilization transport markets, seem to have specific requirements that the Lithium-ion technology, at least in its current state, is no able to satisfy.

Fig. 2: Electric Vehicle Sales by technology

Source: Frost & Sullivan, published 2017BEV: Battery electric vehicle; PHEV: Plug-in hybrid electric vehicle; FCEV: Fuel Cell electric vehicle

It is fairly straightforward to understand why there is a low adoption in these market segments. The long-range transport faces what is perhaps the more important barrier to general EV adoption: range anxiety3. The solution for this issue is not easy; adding more batteries would add to the range, but also lead to a higher price and heavier vehicles. Thus, the conundrum range-price-weight, can only be solved through more efficient batteries rather than a simple addition of batteries. The high-utilization transport segment also faces a significant constraint; due to the nature of its utilization schedules, this segment requires short recharge times; even though fast charging for Lithium-ion batteries is already available, there is a negative impact on battery life4. As such, to serve both these segments, one would require a technology that allows for a reasonably fast charging, and for an acceptable range without a proportional weight increase. Hydrogen fuel cells are thus a good candidate to cater these segments.

How do Hydrogen Fuel Cells Work?

Hydrogen fuel flows to the Anode on one side of the fuel cell; on the other side, an oxidant (oxygen or air) is channeled to the Cathode. At the Anode, a platinum catalyst causes the hydrogen to split into positively hydrogen ions (protons), and negatively charged electrons. At the Cathode, the electrons and positively charged ions combine to form water, which flows out of the cell.

Fig. 3: Visual Representation of the mode of operation

Source: www.intelligent-energy.com

The Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) allows only positively charged ions to pass through it to the Cathode. The negatively charged electrons are then forced to travel along an external circuit to the Cathode, creating electrical current.

Characteristics of rechargeable batteries and hydrogen fuel cells

Fig. 4: Characteristics of rechargeable batteries and hydrogen fuel cells

Source: Cano, Zachary et Al "Batteries and Fuel Cells for emerging electric vehicle markets", Nature Energy, Vol. 3, April 2018, 278-289 (2018)

As the above figure shows, hydrogen can be stored with a specific energy that is far greater than batteries. Following the “no free lunch” principle, hydrogen tanks and fuel-cell systems are relatively expensive, due to the use of platinum, carbon fiber, humidifiers, and heat exchangers5. However, given these physical properties, fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) costs are less sensitive to increased driving range as increasing the range would only require increasing size, quantity, or pressure of hydrogen storage tanks, which are lighter and cheaper than Li-ion battery packs, on a per kWh basis6. As it has been occurring with Lithium-ion battery costs, the increase in production volumes is expected to drive prices of hydrogen tanks and fuel cells down.

Thematic Investments

Our investment teams identify and aim to invest in exciting and attractively valued companies that are on the cutting edge of innovation. Join us and invest in tomorrow’s winners.

The reader may at this point be asking her- or himself, why the industry is not more eager to adopt hydrogen fuel cells instead of Lithium-ion. The answer is nuanced. First, some auto brands are indeed dedicating a significant part of its research effort to FCEVs (Daimler, Toyota, Honda, and Hyundai); however, there are effective barriers to the adoption of FCEVs that require significant investments, specifically related to the development of the hydrogen transportation and distribution infrastructure.

Conclusion

The physical properties of hydrogen fuel cells appear to embed the potential to address the needs of specific segments of the road-transport market. However , it is undeniable that Lithium-ion BEVs are the unrivalled force currently dominating the EV space. The technology race is on, but this is not necessarily a zero sum game between the different technologies. The different advantages and constraints of these technologies may simply result in either technology addressing different market demands.

Regardless of the result of this “race”, it seems clear that the future of road-based transportation will necessarily be composed of widespread EV adoption. As such, the infancy stage of some of technologies, as well as the infrastructure development needs, appear to be a fertile ground of growth and investment opportunities.

Credit Suisse Asset Management has designed strategies to provide clients with “pure-play” exposure to these compelling and complementary long term secular growth themes: Robotics & Automation, Security & Safety, Digital Health, and Infrastructure.

For further information please click here

1 https://cleantechnica.com/2015/04/26/electric-car-history
2 http://enb.iisd.org/vol12/enb12459e.html
3 Li, W., Long, R., Chen, H. & Geng J. “A Review of factors influencing consumer intentions to adopt battery electric vehicles”. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Rev. 78, 318-328 (2017)
4 Gao, Y. et al. “Lithium-ion battery aging mechanisms and life model under different charging stresses”. J. Power Sources 356, 103-114 (2017)
5 Wie, M., Smith, S. J. & Sohn, M.D. „Experience curve development and cost reduction disaggregation for fuel cell markets in Japan and US”. Appl. Energy 191, 346-357 (2017)
6 Cano, Zachary P., Banham, D., Ye, S., Hintennach, A., Lu, Jun, Fowler, M. & Chen, Z. “Batteries and Fuel Cells for emerging electric vehicle markets“, Nature Energy, Vol. 3, April 2018, 278-289 (2018)

IMPORTANT INFORMATION
Fee Disclosure
Where permitted by law, we may receive fees, commissions or other monetary benefits in connection with this product from third parties. For details please refer to your Fee Schedule or contact your Relationship Manager.
If you are not a client of Credit Suisse UK Ltd
If you are not a client of Credit Suisse, please note that this document has been provided to you for information purposes only as an example of the type of products we are able to offer to you should you become a client of Credit Suisse. The provision to you of this document does not constitute an invitation or inducement to buy or sell any security or other financial investment, nor does it constitute an advice or personal recommendation. Should you wish to invest in any products, you will have to go through our account opening process which involves providing us with details of your personal and financial circumstances, risk appetite and investment objectives as well as selecting the most appropriate portfolio mandate for you. We can thereafter work with you to determine which investments are suitable or appropriate for you.
Marketing Disclaimer
This document is provided to you for your information and discussion only. It is not a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument. Any information including facts, opinions or quotations, may be condensed or summarised and is expressed as of the date of writing. The information may change without notice and Credit Suisse (UK) Limited (“Credit Suisse”) is under no obligation to ensure that such updates are brought to your attention.
The price and value of investments mentioned and any income that might accrue could fall or rise or fluctuate. Past performance is not a guide to future performance. If an investment is denominated in a currency other than your base currency consult with such advisor(s) as you consider necessary to assist you in making these determinations. Nothing in this document constitutes legal, accounting or tax advice. Credit Suisse does not advise on the tax consequences of investments and you are advised to contact a tax advisor should you have any questions in this regard. Thek levels and basis of taxation are dependent on individual circumstances and are subject to change.
This document has been prepared from sources Credit Suisse believes to be reliable but we do not guarantee its accuracy or completeness and do not accept liability for any loss arising from its use. Credit Suisse reserves the right to remedy any errors that may be present in this document.
Credit Suisse its affiliates and/or their employees may have a position or holding, or other material interest or effect transactions in any securities mentioned or options thereon, or other investments related thereto and from time to time may add to or dispose of such investments. Credit Suisse may be providing, or have provided within the previous 12 months, significant advice or investment services in relation to the investment concerned or a related investment to any company or issuer mentioned. Some investments referred to in this document will be offered by a single entity or an associate of Credit Suisse or Credit Suisse may be the only market maker in such investments. This document is intended only for the person to whom it is issued by Credit Suisse. It may not be reproduced either in whole, or in part, without our written permission. The distribution of this document and the offer and sale of the investment in certain jurisdictions may be forbidden or restricted by law or regulation.
Investments may have no public market or only a restricted secondary market. Where a secondary market exists, it is not possible to predict the price at which investments will trade in the market or whether such market will be liquid or illiquid. Where such investments will not be listed or traded on any exchange, pricing information may be more difficult to obtain and the liquidity of the investments may be adversely affected. A holder may be able to realise value prior to an investment’s maturity date only at a price in an available secondary market. The Issuer of the investment may have entered into contracts with third parties to create the indicated returns and/or any applicable capital protection (in part or in full). The investment instrument's retention of value is dependent not only on the development of the value of the underlying asset, but also on the creditworthiness of the Issuer and/or Guarantor (as applicable), which may change over the term of the investment instrument. In the event of default by the Issuer and/or Guarantor of the investment and/or any third party, the investment or any income derived from such contracts is not guaranteed and you may get back none of, or less than, what was originally invested. Parties other than the Issuer or Guarantor (as appropriate) mentioned in this document (for instance the Lead Manager, Co-structurer, Calculation Agent or Paying Agent) do neither guarantee repayment of the invested capital nor financial return on the investment product, if nothing is indicated to the contrary.
You may have to accept smaller returns on an investment relative to a direct investment in the underlying index, basket, etc. because of the costs involved in providing the capital protection. Such capital protection normally only applies if the investment is held until maturity. The amount of initial capital to be repaid may be geared, which means that a fall in the underlying index or securities may result in a larger reduction in the amount repaid to investors. Where this document relates to packaged products (such as regulated collective investment schemes), any advice offered to retail clients is based on a selection of products from the whole of the market. Where this document relates to emerging markets you should refer to the Risk Disclosures section of the Credit Suisse Terms of Business. Additional information is, subject to duties of confidentiality, available from Credit Suisse upon request.
Hedge Fund strategies may include the use of leverage (borrowing) and derivative instruments resulting in certain risks, some of which are as follows: leveraged investments, by their nature, increase the potential loss to investors resulting from any depreciation in the value of such investments. Consequently, a relatively small price movement in a leveraged instrument may result in a substantially greater loss to the Hedge Fund. The market in some of the investments made as part of a Fund’s strategy may be relatively illiquid, giving rise to potential difficulties in valuing and disposing of such investments.
Information for determining the value of investments held by a Fund may not be readily available which has corresponding implications for the overall valuation of a Fund. Accurate risk profiling of the Fund
holdings may also not be readily available. Always refer to the Fund’s Prospectus and/or the Key Investor Information Document before making an investment.
Your personal data will be processed in accordance with the Credit Suisse Privacy Policy published at https://www.credit-suisse.com/uk/en/private-banking/important-disclaimer.html.
Credit Suisse (UK) Limited is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority for the conduct of investment business in the United Kingdom. The registered address of Credit Suisse (UK) Limited is Five Cabot Square, London, E14 4QR.
If you have any questions regarding the document, please contact your Relationship Manager.
© Credit Suisse (UK) Limited 2019.